Me. R. Civ. P. 108
Advisory Notes
Rule 108 addresses the requirements for filing child support affidavits, child support worksheets and financial statements as found in Rule 80(c) and real estate certificates found in Rule 80(j). Under subdivision (a), child support affidavits must be filed in all cases where child support is an issue. Child support is always an issue in original actions such as a divorce involving minor children, parental rights and responsibilities actions and parentage and paternity actions. This is a departure from the current rule that requires that child support affidavits be filed in every action involving a minor child. The prior rule was broader than the statute, 19-A M.R.S. §2004(1)(A). The committee believes that in many post-judgment proceedings, such as enforcing and modifying contact rights, child support affidavits are not necessary.
Rule 108 interfaces with Rule 112 because one of the original purposes for requiring the filing of the child support affidavit was to reduce discovery. Rule 112 provides the authority for the court to order the parties to file child support affidavits when not required by Rule 108. Accordingly, when the court (primarily magistrates who have discussions with the parties at conferences) determines that child support should be reviewed, the court can order the parties to file child support affidavits.
Subdivisions (a) (1) and (2) include the qualification and exemption of the Department of Health and Human Services from such filings provided by FAM DIV III.A.2.
Subdivision (b) departs from the prior requirement that parties must file child support worksheets. The experience of magistrates who handle virtually all of these cases suggests that the initial required worksheets are frequently neither filed nor useful to the court. This rule deletes that requirement but permits the court to order the filing of worksheets.
In Lawrence v. Webber 2006 ME 36 ¶ 3 n. 4, 894 A.2d 480, the Law Court noted that the trial court may have been aided had the parties filed child support worksheets as required by 19-A M.R.S. §2004(1)(C). The magistrates, however, are in a better position to know the appropriate time to order the parties to file worksheets, which will usually be before hearings and conferences. The court now has available software programs that perform worksheet calculation functions upon entry of appropriate income and other figures.
In subdivision (c), financial statements must be filed in all divorce or judicial separation actions where division of property, spousal support, or counsel fees is an issue. The rule is developed from Rule 80(c). Rule 80(c), however, neither limits the requirement for filing of financial statements to divorce and judicial separation actions nor includes counsel fees as an issue. In practice, however, financial statements are filed only in the two original actions. Also, the court-approved financial statement form refers to counsel fees. Rule 108 interfaces with Rule 112 because the filing of the financial statement triggers discovery. In practice, financial statements were not filed in post-judgment motions or parental rights and responsibilities complaints so that triggering discovery with the filing of the financial statement does not make sense. The committee believes that the rule should reflect practice. Division of property is only an issue in original actions. Although spousal support and counsel fees may be issues in both original actions and post-judgment motions, Rule 108 requires that the financial statement be filed only in the original action, which is the current practice. Rule 112 provides that the court, on its own motion or at the request of the parties, may order the filing of financial statements in any proceeding under this chapter in which it would assist in discovery or otherwise be appropriate.
Subdivision (c) also changes the time period for filing the financial statement. Often in practice, the financial statement was exchanged at mediation which does not adequately permit the parties to prepare for mediation. The filing of the financial statement shall be ordered in the Family Division Scheduling Order to be within 21 days of the date of the order or before mediation, whichever is earlier. Finally, subdivision (c) also provides the court with authority to shorten or lengthen the time period for filing the financial statement as appropriate.
Subdivision (d) outlines other miscellaneous requirements located in Rule 80(c).
Subdivision (e) relating to filing a real estate certificate is included in Rule 108 so that all required supplemental financial and asset filing requirements are contained within one rule.
Subdivision (f) relates to actions the court may take if there is a failure to file required materials. Subsection (f) (1) is based on Rule 80(c). It indicates that if a party fails to file any required affidavit, worksheet, financial statement, or real estate certificate required by this rule, the court may make such orders in regard to the failure to file as are just, including the imposition of sanctions as appropriate. The rule clarifies that magistrates are not permitted to impose any sanctions or penalties based upon a determination of contempt under Rule 66.
Subdivision (f) (2) is based on FAM DIV III.H.2. It authorizes entry of child support orders notwithstanding a party’s failure to file affidavits and sets the process by which the court may determine income levels for assessment of child support. It also allows the court to impose certain obligations for filing upon non-cooperating parties and it allows award of attorney fees. All of this is as provided in FAM DIV III.H.2.
Advisory Committee Note – July 1, 2010
The seven-day updating requirement is moved from Rule 112(d) to become Rule 108(d)(4), where it is more appropriately placed. The updating requirement is not changed, except to clarify that the updated statements must be prepared and filed. Rule 108(d) is also amended to place a heading in each paragraph.
Advisory Note – July 2016
Some changes were made to correct typographical or grammatical errors, others in an attempt to improve the readability of the rule. The new language in the last sentence of Rule 108(a)(1) clarifies each party’s obligation to timely file a child support affidavit. The change to Rule 108(f)(2) imposes an obligation on the court to issue a child support order within 63 days after the case management conference, unless the court is satisfied that the child(ren)’s needs are being met. This change reflects a suggestion contained in the FDTF 2014 report to “enforce” Rule 108. Numbering conventions were changed to be consistent with the Rules as a whole.